Both Rock Band 2 and Guitar Hero: World tour had a pretty big presence at PAX. I didn’t feel like waiting in line for either of them but I did find myself stopping to watch various nerds’ rock just about any time I was walking by them.

The showdown: Rock Band 2 vs. Guitar Hero: World Tour

Harmonix had a single setup on a large stage that gave a rock concert vibe aside from the occasionally terrible singing. There was almost always a crowd around the stage watching or waiting in line to play. Overall it looks like a nice update to the original. Same basic setup with some minor tweaks like better sorting options on the song selection screen. One feature that I’m excited about is the inclusion of a no fail mode which should make it easier to get amateur fake rockers into the game. The new drums seemed quite a bit quieter but of course there was loud music all over the hall so it’s tough to say for sure.

Activision on the other hand chose to have 4 or 5 smaller GH: WT setups. It wasn’t quite as cool to watch but it did allow for more hands on time for anyone who was interested. Really GH: WT looks almost exactly like Rock Band. There’s a slight difference in color and the notes are round but in general the layout is pretty much the same. Of course the drums are a bit different, there are 3 toms and 2 cymbals.

I’ll probably end up buying both RB2 and GH: WT eventually. I’m more excited about Rock Band 2 but since Guitar Hero: World Tour is compatible with my current RB setup I don’t see any harm in getting both.

I ended up arriving late and had to wait for over an hour in the will call line to pick up my pre-ordered
badge. Which was mildly annoying since it was only a two minute wait to buy a badge. Right after I got out of the badge line I got in line for the keynote, there were a lot of lines at PAX.

Ken Levine’s keynote was entertaining. He gave a brief overview of his history as a nerd. From his early days of wanting to fuck the scarlet witch and his first awkward experiences with D&D all the way to his failed screenwriting career and his decision to go get into the game industry and join Looking Glass Studios. The theme of the whole boiled down to “We’re all geeks, love it, embrace it and go have fun together”.

I skipped the Q&A panel to hit the exhibit floor. After a quick walk around I stopped and checked out Rock Band 2 and Guitar Hero: World Tour . I discovered that Brawndo The Thirst Mutilator, did indeed have what I (and plants) crave. It’s pretty tasty but oddly not got sale. (I’ve since learned that it wasn’t for sale because the convention center doesn’t allow non-convention vendors to sell food or drink)

Nintendo was nearby so I checked out some of their stuff. WarioLand: Shake It seems like a decent platformer although depending on how much it’s used; constantly shaking the controller could get annoying. Kirby Superstar Ultra was fun but there really isn’t much new about it. After that, I had some fun creating a creature in Spore Creature Creator for the DS. I couldn’t do anything more than walk around with it once it was created which makes me what the game play would be like in that game. I finished off my day in the exhibit hall with Left 4 Dead which was amazing.

Next up I hit the concerts. It was probably the strangest concert I’ve ever been too. No one was really getting into any of the bands mostly everyone was just sort of hanging out listening. The OneUps were kind of neat but it sounded a lot like they were just jamming the whole time and not really playing songs. Freezepop isn’t really my thing but they ended up being pretty good. During their entire set, there was a guy nearby playing Final Fantasy Tactics which was odd. Freezepop’s encore ended up being a cover of The Final Countdown and it was really good.

Finally Jonathan Coulton was up. I wasn’t really looking forward to seeing him but figured it would be cool to see “Still Alive” from Portal performed live. Of course, I was completely wrong and he ended up being the best of them all, I suppose that’s why he was “headlining”. I enjoyed all his songs, my favorite was “re: Your Brains” there is nothing cooler than a room of people out of sync and groaning “All we want to do is eat your brains”. He also managed to Rick Roll the whole audience twice. The first time the video played over the projectors and most of the crowd started singing along. The second time was mixed in the middle of “Mr. Fancy Pants”. For “Still Alive” Felicia Day, who is like geek goddess, came out and sang with him. He ended the night with a sing along cover of Neil Diamond’s “Sweet Caroline” which was unexpected and really cool. Over all, Day One was amazing.

Pictures still to come.